Skip to the content

Rural Hospitals More Likely to Leverage General Physicians Than Specialists to Treat Patient Population


by Sheri Sorrell and Alycia Kaufmann

Rural hospitals are in a fragile economic state. Since 2010, 106 rural hospitals have closed. At the time of this report, the Rural Health Web estimates another 700 rural hospitals – roughly one-third of the 1,875 rural community hospitals remaining – are vulnerable or at risk for closure.

While all hospitals are under economic pressure, the challenges facing rural hospitals far surpass those faced by urban facilities. In general, rural community hospitals must navigate through higher rates of uncompensated care, a greater percentage of patients who are uninsured or insured by government programs (Medicare and Medicaid) which typically reimburse at a rate lower than private insurance, and a decline in inpatient admissions.

Rural hospitals are left burdened, unable to invest in new technology that would advance patient treatment and diagnosis, and unable to offer recruitment packages that would attract and retain highly experienced and specialized physicians. The resulting outmigration of patients who perceive better care and easier access in urban areas further strains rural hospitals.

Thus, the physician shortage is keenly felt in these rural communities. Twenty percent of the U.S. population lives in rural areas, but only 12% of primary care physicians and 8% of physician specialists practice in rural areas. From 2013 to 2015, the physician population in the U.S. grew by 16,000 practitioners, while the number of rural physicians dropped by 1,400.

1/3 of rural hospitals are at risk for closure.

The shortage of physicians in rural areas is further complicated by the medical profile of patients living in these areas, who tend to be older and in poorer health. A 2017 study from the CDC demonstrates that rural Americans are more likely to die from five leading causes:

  • Heart disease
  • Cancer
  • Unintentional injuries
  • Chronic lower respiratory disease
  • Stroke
Are rural hospitals embracing locum tenens as a solution to the rural physician shortage?

Rural hospitals need access to specialists.

Locum tenens offer an immediate solution for the rural physician shortage. But are rural hospitals embracing that solution?

A recent study by Jackson Healthcare in partnership with Jackson & Coker sought to understand the usage of locum tenens physicians among the Medicare population in the U.S. The aim was to identify ways to improve patient access to primary and mental health care for the most underserved. In a retrospective analysis of Medicare encounters in 2017, the study found rural hospitals make use of locum tenens general practitioners in greater numbers than they do specialists.

Methodology. The study compared care received from locum tenens physicians by Medicare patients in both rural and urban settings in 2017. Using a 5% sample of the year’s data, our research assessed the type of care delivered based on the physician’s National Provider Identifier in the Carrier File.

Findings. Among the interesting findings in the study:

  • Of patients seen by locum tenens practitioners in rural areas, 72% in the sample were attended by diagnostic radiologists, compared to 58% of patients in urban areas.

  • Rural Medicare patients are more likely to see diagnostic radiologists and general practitioners in the Emergency Room than urban patients. Urban Medicare patients are more likely to see internal medicine subspecialists and emergency medicine subspecialists in the ER.

  • Even in an inpatient hospital setting, rural patients are more likely to see diagnostic radiologists and general practitioners than urban patients. Interestingly, urban patients are more likely to encounter Advanced Practice professionals (PAs and NPs).

 

Conclusion and Relevance. The study illustrates the increased availability of specialist physicians, including those working locum tenens, in urban settings. It further highlights processes rural hospitals have designed to expeditiously treat patients in the Emergency Room despite a lack of physician specialists. The study raises additional questions that should be tackled to improve care access.

Further questions to explore include:

  • Are general practitioners in rural areas using Diagnostic Radiology to compensate for the lack of specialists in these areas?
Rural hospitals have created processes to treat ER patients despite lack of specialists.
  • Why are rural hospitals not making use of locum tenens physicians in subspecialties? Is it cost related?

  • Why don’t rural hospitals utilize Advanced Practice Professionals more? Is it because they do not have a physician supervisor or do other practice authority limitations play a role?

  • What recruitment strategies would attract specialists to rural settings? Additionally, what retention strategies are needed?

 

Looking for a PDF version of this report?

Rural Hospitals More Likely to Leverage General Physicians Than Specialists to Treat Patient Population

This study is a collaboration of effort by Jackson & Coker and Jackson Healthcare.

 

About Jackson Healthcare

Jackson Healthcare®, the third-largest U.S. healthcare staffing firm by revenue, is a family of highly-specialized healthcare staffing, search and technology companies. With a mission to improve the delivery of patient care and the lives of everyone it touches, it helps thousands of healthcare facilities serve more than seven million patients annually. Backed by more than 1,500 associates and with over $1 billion in annual revenue, Jackson Healthcare is recognized as an employer of choice, having appeared in consecutive years on Fortune’s Best Workplaces in Health Care and Biopharma list, in 2019 on the Best Workplaces for Women list and in 2018 on the Best Workplaces for Millennials list, as well as being named a best place to work by the Atlanta Business Chronicle since 2005. Learn more by visiting www.jacksonhealthcare.com.

About Jackson & Coker

Jackson & Coker is among the most well-recognized healthcare staffing firms in the United States. The firm – offering staffing solutions for locum tenens, locums-to-permanent, telehealth and oversight and review – is dedicated to uniting top physicians and advanced practitioners with the hospitals and medical facilities that need them, ensuring patients have access to life-saving healthcare in their own communities.

Since the 1970s, Jackson & Coker has placed thousands of healthcare providers with clients ranging from rural clinics to the United States’ largest healthcare systems. It has been ranked a “Best Staffing Firm to Work For” by Staffing Industry Analysts, one of “America’s Best Professional Recruiting Firms” by Forbes and a “Best Place to Work” by Atlanta Business Chronicle.

At Jackson & Coker, “We focus on you – the patient’s true hero.”

How may we help?

Call us anytime 1-800-272-2707.